Menu

We dream up all our flavors in-house, using only the best ingredients. From classics to unexpected twists, there’s something here for every craving.

Flavors

Baba’s Depot

Toasted coconut cake, coconut almond pastry cream, & coconut buttercream

Cowboy No. 14

Carrot cake, maple pecan-pie filling, & brown butter cream cheese frosting

Garden State

Vanilla bean cake, berry jam, fresh berries, & vanilla bean buttercream

Mimi’s Special

Almond cake, raspberry jam, & brown butter buttercream

Mischief Night

Chocolate cake, chocolate fudge, & chocolate buttercream

School Bus Sally

Funfetti cake, edible sprinkle cookie dough, & funfetti vanilla bean buttercream

The Shore

Lemon poppy-seed cake, lemon curd, & vanilla bean buttercream

Traffic Jam on 24th

Vanilla bean cake, strawberry jam, & strawberry buttercream

Seasonal Flavors

Gemini Season

Lemon olive oil cake, blackberry jam, & honey lemon buttercream

Jersey Peach

Vanilla cardamom cake, peach pie filling, & brown butter buttercream

  • Baba's Depot

  • Cowboy No. 14

  • Garden State

  • Mimi's Special

  • Mischief Night

  • School Bus Sally

  • The Shore

  • Traffic Jam on 24th

Additional Information

Allergies

Our cakes are made in a kitchen that handles gluten, nuts, dairy, and soy. While we take precautions, we cannot guarantee items are allergen-free. Please let us know of any allergies when placing your order. We do not make dairy-free or vegan cakes at this time.

We offer gluten-free cakes for an extra fee starting at $5 extra (varies by cake size). Additionally, we do not make dairy-free or vegan cakes at this time.

Custom Cake Flavor

If you have a flavor in mind that isn’t on our menu, we’d be happy to work with you to create it. With enough notice, we can accommodate unique flavors, fillings, or special dietary needs.